Building Healthy Communities from the Ground up

Press Release – CARB’s Draft Scoping Plan and Environmental Justice Recommendations


May 10, 2022


Isa Flores-Jones, Communications Manager

Environmental Justice Groups Slam California’s Draft 20-year Climate Plan, Say it “Paves the Way for Billions in Public Subsidies to Fossil Fuel Corporations”

Environmental Justice groups urge the California Air Resources Board to phase out fossil fuels by 2045 and build a clean energy future that works for all Californians.

SACRAMENTO, CA – Today, the California Air Resources Board released a draft of the state’s 2022 Climate Change Scoping Plan Update, a blueprint that will guide the next 20 years of climate action in California. Environmental justice groups slammed the draft plan, citing its failure to phase out fossil fuel production, lack of investment in clean transportation for low-income Californians, and dependence on failed carbon capture and other polluting technologies to meet climate targets.

“The California Air Resources Board’s draft Climate Change Scoping Plan is disastrous for climate and leaves working class Californians behind,” said Martha Dina Arguello, Executive Director of Physicians for Social Responsibility-Los Angeles and Co-Chair of the Air Resources Board Environmental Justice Advisory Committee. “At a time when California needs to be phasing out fossil fuels, our top air regulators are bowing to fossil fuel lobbyists at the expense of our health and future.”

California’s draft Climate Change Scoping Plan Update includes:

  • Oil Refining and Extraction: No target date or plan for phaseout of oil refining.  Instead, the draft Scoping Plan proposes carbon capture and storage on the majority of operations by 2030. Follows Newsom’s Executive Order to phase out oil extraction by 2045.  
  • Electricity: Increases gas-fired power generation by 10 gigawatts (equivalent to 30 new, mid-sized gas-fired power plants). 
  • Transportation: Delays 100% ZEV medium- and heavy-duty truck sales from 2035 to 2040. Minimal reductions in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) – 12% reduction in VMT by 2030, 22% reduction in VMT by 2045.
  • Carbon Capture and Storage: Puts carbon capture and storage on majority of operations by 2030. Puts carbon capture and storage on 40% of operations in stone, clay, glass, and cement plants.  

In March, environmental justice groups submitted a comment letter urging the state’s top air regulators to prioritize direct emissions reduction measures, including: 

  1. Plan for a full coordinated phaseout of fossil fuels by 2045, including a phaseout of oil refining by 2045 and oil extraction by 2035, and transition to clean, renewable, zero-emissions electricity by 2045 at the latest.  
  2. Accelerate and scale up investment in clean cars, trucks, and mass transit for low-income Californians through 100% ZEV sales of medium- and heavy-duty trucks and a 30% reduction in VMT by 2035.
  3. Eliminate the state’s reliance on climate dead ends like carbon capture and storage.  

The fossil fuel chain of vehicles, oil refineries, and oil extraction makes up nearly 50% of the state’s greenhouse gas emissions. 

“By pouring billions into the Big Oil scheme for carbon capture and storage at California’s oil refineries, the Air Resources Board’s draft climate plan extends the life of our otherwise defunct polluting fossil fuel infrastructure,” said Connie Cho, attorney at Communities for a Better Environment.  “We need a full, coordinated phase out of fossil fuels by 2045.  Communities need clear timelines and a real commitment to planning a just transition – to build a strong safety net for fossil fuel workers and communities, invest in developing healthy local economies with good family-supporting jobs, and clean up toxic sites. If we wait until the industry is on its deathbed and bankrupt, we’re too late. Workers and communities will be left behind.”

“From the placement of freeways in working class communities of color in the mid-1900s to the concentration of diesel truck pollution around ports and warehouse hubs, working class communities of color have been disproportionately impacted by transportation emissions,” said Kyle Heiskala, Climate Justice Policy Advocate with Environmental Health Coalition. “Now, with rising gas prices, our communities are feeling the pain at the pump.  We need a climate plan that accelerates and scales up investment in clean vehicles, and mass transit for working class Californians.”

“At a time when we need to be planning for a phaseout of fossil fuels, our top air regulators are instead planning for a massive expansion of dirty gas-fired power plants,” said Ari Eisenstadt, Regenerate California Campaign Manager with California Environmental Justice Alliance.  “Strategies like electrifying buildings and transitioning to electric vehicles only fulfill their potential for decarbonization if we ensure that our electricity is generated from clean, renewable energy sources.”

This year is the first time that the Air Resources Board has included dependence on carbon capture, utilization, and sequestration (CCUS) for industrial pollution in the state’s climate action plan. 

Despite decades of attempts by fossil fuel corporations, carbon capture technology has failed to produce results.  In the United States, big polluters have attempted 39 CCUS projects. Over 80% of these CCUS projects never opened or shut down.  None of these projects met their promised emissions reductions. In most cases, carbon capture projects resulted in more emissions than the projects captured.  

“Fossil fuel executives are using carbon capture to dig up and burn more oil, fueling the flames of climate change,” said Dan Ress, staff attorney for the Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment. “Most captured carbon dioxide is used to pressurize old, dead oil wells to suck up the dirtiest, stickiest crude oil at the bottom of the well and burn it. CARB’s climate plan paves the way for billions in public subsidies for ineffective, dangerous carbon capture projects that pad the profits of fossil fuel corporations.”

Globally, 80% of captured carbon is used for Enhanced Oil Recovery.  Using captured carbon for enhanced oil recovery produces 4 times more carbon from burning the oil than it sequesters.  

“California has a wealth of proven strategies to cut emissions, protect our health, and stabilize our climate – increased electrification through clean renewable energy, decarbonizing the state’s aging housing stock, deepening energy efficiency upgrades, scaling up investments in mass transit.” said Amee Raval, Policy Director at Asian Pacific Environmental Network. “Winding down consumption of fossil fuels is only half of the equation. These strategies only work if we commit to phasing out production of fossil fuels and other dirty, polluting energy sources.  Otherwise, we risk turning California into an export hub for dirty fuels.”

The California Air Resources Board will meet in late June to review and make changes to the draft Climate Change Scoping Plan.


CARB’s Draft Scoping Plan and Environmental Justice Recommendations


Download this chart here as a PDF.

Find additional quotes here from environmental justice and environmental organizations.